Sonderkommandos in the Killing Centers
Although the situation differed among camps, the purpose and daily life of the Sonderkommandos were similar. The routine of the Sonderkommando of the Auschwitz II (Birkenau) killing center is a representative example of the larger phenomenon.
The Jews of this work brigade fulfilled many roles in the gas chamber/crematoria complex, beginning with the arrival of victims. Sonderkommando Jews were present in the undressing area, instructing arriving victims to undress and how to arrange their clothing, which would later be confiscated by the SS.
After the gassing was carried out by camp personnel, men of the Sonderkommando entered the gas chamber, untangled bodies, and cleaned the by then ventilated room. An elevator then raised the bodies to the crematorium level. There, another group would shave the hair of the victims and search the bodies for hidden valuables, including gold teeth, which were removed and handed over to the SS. Finally, the Sonderkommando Jews would carry out the burning of bodies in the ovens and the disposal of the ashes.
In camps like Belzec, Sobibor, and Treblinka, which lacked the more complex machinery of Auschwitz, Sonderkommando prisoners still fulfilled many of the same tasks. Further, to destroy the evidence of mass murder, Sonderkommando were forced to exhume the bodies from burial pits and burn them. The use of the Sonderkommando thus relieved SS personnel from the more disturbing tasks associated with mass murder.
Work in the Sonderkommando was physically exhausting and psychologically destructive. These prisoners were forbidden from warning the incoming victims of their fate and were forced to participate in the process of killing. The prisoners' days were numbered. Members of the Sonderkommando were routinely shot. Of all the prisoners in the camp, they knew the most about the Nazi "Final Solution" and could not be permitted to survive to testify. They were usually kept completely apart from the rest of the prisoners, either in the gas chamber complex itself or in separate barracks.
The men forced to do the horrific work of the Sonderkommandos did not do so without resistance. Thanks to one commando worker, Greek prisoner Alberto Errara, four photos from Auschwitz documenting the Sonderkommando in action survived the war. These images, smuggled out by the Polish resistance, are some of the few photographs which are known to depict events near the gas chambers at Auschwitz-Birkenau.
Furthermore, Sonderkommandos participated in armed revolts. One example was at Auschwitz in October 1944. At Auschwitz, the Sonderkommando in all four main crematoria revolted. Crematorium IV was destroyed, and Sonderkommando members from Crematorium III managed to escape briefly. Some 250 prisoners died fighting and a further 200 were murdered in the revolt's aftermath. Three SS men were killed, while around ten were injured.
Sonderkommandos in Other Locations
Killing centers were not the only locations where Sonderkommandos were used.
In May 1942, under the Sonderkommando 1005 program, the SS, led by former Einsatzgruppe commander Paul Blobel, was tasked with excavating and destroying evidence of Nazi murder across the occupied east. Jewish prisoners and Soviet prisoners of war were forced to unearth and burn the bodies of Jews and other victims who had been shot or murdered earlier in the war. These groups performed many of the same tasks of the Sonderkommandos in the camps. They also resisted. Prisoners from these Sonderkommandos revolted and escaped from the Ponary Forest execution site and the Ninth Fort, both in Lithuania, as well as the Janowska camp in German-occupied Poland.
The Sonderkommando were forced to perform tasks of unimaginable horror and brutality. Usually, they were aware that they would be murdered after a few months of work. Those who made the difficult decision to resist or refuse to follow orders risked immediate death. They faced horrific circumstances and dilemmas that have been the subject of study by scholars and filmmakers.
Critical Thinking Questions
- Why did the SS murder the Sonderkommando every few months and train a new group?
- How does learning about the Sonderkommando underline the systematic nature of the "Final Solution"?
- Why is it difficult to judge the choices of individuals in the Sonderkommando? As with all persons, in the Holocaust or an event of extreme brutality, consider the pressures and motivations which may have affected any choices they may have had.